The Emotional Connection To Characters In Dystopia

If you've read 1984 why did you care about the story? And Animal Farm and Fahrenheit 451 and Brave New World and Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep? Really, what was it about these most disturbed you?

For a lot of these stories you might say it was the ideas about societies, about governments, about the individual in the face of the vast and overpowering mass forces insisting on the protagonists's surrender to a stifling conformity. And you would be right. However, besides the sort of big picture, intellectual aspects to these stories there is something else going on as well; for any story to be really engaging, there is key element that probably needs to be in place for any story to work, and that is a strong emotional connection to at least one of the characters, probably the protagonist. The emotional connection to a character has to be strong for the reader even though the reader is also being transported to a strange and distant world, so that the reader has a part of the story they can allow to get deep into their consciousness.

This way even though the reader is being take to a place they've never been and may not really be able to understand, they still feel like they are in that world in an intense way. I as the reader may not be able to comprehend the way the technology in a science fiction story works, or how the society being presented became the way that it did. But seeing a universal human story is something I can comprehend whatever the setting it is portrayed in. It's been shown that reading books and empathizing with the characters not only is an artistic experience, but one that actually helps us form empathy for others more in real life (See story from The Guardian). This suggests that there's something quite profound about the ways in which books can make us empathize characters. Something deep going on.

?format=500w

In a sense the genius of Star Wars (I'm talking about the old ones, Episode IV - VI) is the way in which the films presented really archetypal ideas in a setting 'a long time ago in a galaxy far far away'. Luke Skywalker looks out on two sunsets that are a metaphor for having to choose between two paths in life, Han Solo has troubles with adversaries that could almost exist in a story by Mark Twain, Luke and Leia are siblings and don't even know it, Luke learns from an older and wiser man a new way to be, and Luke has the ultimate Oedipal confrontation with the father he never knew. The way in which these universal themes were seamlessly embedded into a world of spaceships and aliens and laser guns and laser swords and telepathy are a big part of why the films became so iconic.

Or take the emotional connection readers can find to Winston Smith in 1984. I like to talk about this example of an emotional connection to a dystopian protagonist because I think it's not talked about enough in the many conversations this seminal book has created. (Spoiler alerts but stop this and go read the damn thing if you haven't) What we see so much in the book is not just Winston Smith, the defenseless victim of a monstrous government; we also get to know Winston Smith, the vulnerable man with hopes and dreams. Winston's vulnerability is on display several times, whether it's his inability to have a private moment, to make his own decisions about when to awake, about what to read, or who to have a relationship with. We see Winston is terrified of rats, but that his girlfriend is brave in the face of them, underscoring the vulnerability of his phobia by comparison. We see Winston the man who is tricked by O'Brien, Winston who can't even try to escape from the soldiers who come after him or resist when they savagely beat him in prison. We hear about Winston the oft-suffering child who just wanted the simple pleasure of playing a game to forget about his famine for a while.  And finally Winston who will give up anything and give in to Big Brother when pressed against his deepest fears. By the end of the story how can you not feel deeply connected to Winston, and also more depressed than you've been in years?

Vulnerability or impotence or social disadvantage or some sort of outsider status is one of the things I notice in a lot of these stories. Some form of weakness or downcast position, most especially in the way the protagonist views their self. Winston Smith, Guy Montag and Bernard Marx are all weak men in certain ways, or at least weak in comparison to the forces much larger than themselves, which their questioning minds inevitably bring them into a confrontation with. In a sense they show that a weak character is an interesting one, or at least a partially weak character, a character who has at least some serious disadvantages they work against. When a character is all strength and ability and success and triumph it gets boring pretty fast.

In my own writing this is what I was tending towards on some level; it just made sense to have my protagonist have some serious lack of control over a lot of his life. I wanted him to be partly a rational thinker, but partly a person often distracted by his intuitive emotional reactions to things, whose rationality is not always perfect and who faces a situation where the 'rational' answer isn't so obvious.

What are some of your emotional connections to dystopian or Sci Fi or other fictional characters? These ones and/or those in other works? I know there are many examples of this.

KOQGXCqEwJI

Comics & Graphic Novels Posts

Aug 14, 2015

SF Review: Doctor Who: The Drosten’s Curse by A.L. Kennedy

By Escape Reality, Read Fiction!

My Review: Tomorrow, Saturday August 15, has been declared Doctor Who Comics Day by Titan Comics, who, of course, publish Doctor Who Comics. While I didn’t have a Doctor Who...

Jul 27, 2015

Justice League: Gods & Monsters (Review)

By Comics Worth Reading

Justice League: Gods & Monsters is the best of the DC original animated movies in a long while. That’s because it’s fresh. It’s based on an original story by Bruce...

Jul 11, 2015

Phoebe and Her Unicorn: A Heavenly Nostrils Chronicle

By Comics Worth Reading

When a friend recommended the Phoebe and Her Unicorn comic strip (formerly known as Heavenly Nostrils) to me, she described it as a more modern, girl-centered Calvin and Hobbes. She...

Jul 08, 2015

Atari Force Returns!

By Comics Worth Reading

As I’ve said before, I really liked Atari Force. Yes, it was originally a home-video-game tie-in, but the 20-issue series by (as Mike Sterling reminds us), Gerry Conway and Jose...

Jul 06, 2015

Black Canary #1

By Comics Worth Reading

Brenden Fletcher and Annie Wu put a new twist on the long-running fishnet-clad hero in Black Canary. Looked at after reading, it’s a terrific choice, but not one I would...

Jul 06, 2015

Starfire #1

By Comics Worth Reading

I’ve been trying a number of the new DC #1s, particularly the ones promising something other than the usual legacy white male hero, but I’ve found some of them unsatisfying....

Jun 08, 2015

Gotham Home Video Date Announced

By Comics Worth Reading

The hit Fox (non-)superhero show Gotham has been announced for release on Blu-ray and DVD on September 8. Gotham was Fox’s highest rated fall drama debut in 14 years among...

Jun 29, 2015

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Volume 14

By Comics Worth Reading

I’m so glad to get another volume of The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service! (The previous book, volume 13, last appeared at the end of 2012.) Although it’s horror, it’s one...

Jun 28, 2015

The Cartoon Guide to Algebra

By Comics Worth Reading

It amazes me that Larry Gonick is still turning out such interesting cartoon science guides. I remember reading my first one, The Cartoon Guide to (Non)Communication, back in the early...

Jun 08, 2015

Doctor Who: The Tenth Doctor #11

By Comics Worth Reading

I know big, galaxy-risking, four-part stories are seen as more important, but it’s the one-off, quieter, more personal scenes that I really like in this series. I shouldn’t be too...