Fantasy Review: The Aeronaut's Windlass by Jim Butcher

book review, historical fantasy, jim butcher, sci-fi, steampunk, suvudu


I thoroughly enjoyed The Aeronaut's Windlass, no doubt about it. It was a fast-paced, action-packed, imaginative bit of fiction with a lot of elements that appealed to me. Where Jim Butcher's steampunk(ish) adventure fell a bit short, however, was in terms of characterization and description.

The characters here are all genre archetypes, as if Butcher was just going down a list, making sure he checked all the boxes. That's not to say that some of them weren't interesting - I admired Captain Grimm and loved the scenes with the Master Ferus and his assistant, Folly - but they all seem like characters we've read before. They're characters who fill a role and serve a purpose, but who don't exhibit much in the way of personality. To make matters worse, I didn't find Gwen particularly likable, which is an issue when she's front-and-center to so much of the novel.

The lack of description, which you can get away with in a more familiar urban fantasy setting, is sure to be an issue for many readers here. Butcher has crafted a fascinating new society, living high in in the clouds, but it's all as ethereal as the magic-like technology that supports it. There's very little detail here to explain what it all looks like, and how it all fits together. This is one of those books where I'd gladly overlook the addition of one more character archetype (the outsider) to wander around and comment on everything he sees, just so we could see it alongside him. I'm an imaginative fellow, with a fondness for weird and unusual places, but even I had trouble forming a mental picture of where we were and what was going on.

Having said all that, there were some fun elements. The naval battles were definitely the highlight of the book for me, taking traditional sea-faring to the skies, and augmenting it with laser-like weapons and shields that are very much space opera inspired. Dialogue was hit-or-miss, with the witty banter often feeling a little forced, but the bewildering confusion of conversation with Ferus and Folly was an example of a genre trope that Butcher completely owned and excelled at. Initially, I wasn't too thrilled with the inclusion of talking cats, but Rowl defintitely has his moments, rising about the animal-familiar archetype to become one of my favorite characters.

Ultimately, The Aeronaut's Windlass is a fun read, but neither a deep one nor a particularly memorable one. It's the literary equivalent of an old-time adventure serial, one where we gleefully ignore the cliches and forgive the wooden delivery so long as the action keeps us moving along. You can walk away from it with a smile, having enjoyed the ride, but you really do hope the memories will fade before they're spoiled by any serious thought or reflection.

Paperback, 512 pages
Expected publication: September 29th 2015 by Orbit

Disclaimer: I received a complimentary ARC of this title from the publisher in exchange for review consideration.This does not in any way affect the honesty or sincerity of my honest review.
© 2015 Beauty in Ruins All Rights Reserved

Editor's Picks Posts

Jan 19, 2015

H.P. Lovecraft Rises Again…as a Delicious Honey Ale

By RetroZap!

Narragansett Beer has released the first in a four-part series honoring the legendary writer. The year was 1890, and, all in all it was a pretty good year. Up here...

Nov 03, 2014
Oct 06, 2014

NYCC Survival Tips - Enter now!

By Emily Hughes

Tell us your best comic con survival tips and you could win big!

Sep 17, 2014

Deconstructing the Doctor: Peter Capaldi & the New Series

By Emily Hughes

On Peter Capaldi, Clara Oswald, and that mysterious Promised Land...

Sep 12, 2014
Aug 22, 2014

Doctor Who Series 8: GET EXCITED

By Emily Hughes

Livetweeting & giveaways galore!

Aug 12, 2014

Star Trek author David Mack issues barn-burning rebuttal to homophobic reader

By Emily Hughes

“Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations," indeed.

Aug 11, 2014

Doctor Who: 12 Days to 12

By Emily Hughes

Capaldi countdown...

Aug 06, 2014

Lev Grossman Interview:

By Emily Hughes

The Magicians Trilogy author really wants to write for Adventure Time.

Jul 29, 2014